Understanding Church Background Checks: Importance and Best Practices

Church should be a safe place for everyone. It should be a place where people can come and meet with God without fear of anything happening. Parents should know their children are safe so that they can worship without distraction. Children should sense they are safe in the care of children's ministry volunteers and church employees.

Unfortunately, and horrifically, church has not always been a safe place for everyone. We've all heard the stories of children and other vulnerable people abused in various ways by church volunteers and employees. No one, child or otherwise, should have to endure such a thing.

This highlights the utmost importance (I cannot put enough emphasis on the word "utmost") of church background checks.

Church background checks are a necessary and critical step in ensuring the safety and security of everyone within the church community.

In this guide, we'll talk in-depth about church background checks. We'll discuss what they are, why they're necessary, and best practices for churches.

‍

What Are Church Background Checks?

A background check is a thorough, in-depth review of a person's criminal, employment, and personal history to ensure their safety and suitability to serve or work in a particular role in a church.

Background checks cover numerous areas of a person's life, including:

• Criminal background checks: This involves searching through local, state, and federal criminal databases to check for any previous convictions or charges.
  
  
• Sex offender registry checks: Checking to see if the person is registered as a sex offender.
  
  
• Identity verification: Unfortunately, there are some people who are not who they claim to be. Identify verification checks ensure that a person is not lying about who they are.
  
  
• Reference checks: This involves contacting the references provided by the person to confirm their character and suitability for a role in the church.
  
  
• Credit history checks: For positions involving church finances, a credit check is necessary. It helps to ensure the person has a good track record of handling money.
  
  
• Employment history: Verifying the person's past employment history can give insight into their work ethic and potential red flags.
  
  
• Motor vehicle records checks: If an individual will be providing transport to church members, a driving history check is critical.

‍

Who Should Be Screened In Church Background Checks?

Anyone who will be working or serving on behalf of a church should have a background check. This includes:

• Pastors, clergy, and ministry leaders
• Church staff, employees, and volunteers
• Sunday school teachers and youth group leaders
• Childcare workers and nursery attendants
• Security team members
• Drivers for church events or transportation services

It's important to note that background checks should not be used to discriminate against individuals. They are meant to ensure the safety and protection of the church community. Therefore, everyone in these roles should undergo a background check regardless of age, race, gender, or other personal characteristics.

‍

Why Are Background Checks So Important For Churches?

Unfortunately, we all know why background checks are necessary. The reality is we live in a sinful and broken world. As much as we want to believe that everyone who enters our church doors has good intentions, the sad truth is that there are people who may try to harm others or take advantage of vulnerable individuals. Church background checks help prevent these situations from occurring and protect the church community.

Specifically, background checks are an essential method of protecting the most vulnerable members of the church: children, the elderly, individuals in a crisis, etc.

There are legal and liability considerations as well. In the event of an incident, churches can be held responsible for not properly screening their employees and volunteers. Background checks demonstrate due diligence and help protect the church from potential lawsuits.

Background checks also help maintain trust between the church leadership and the members. Congregants want to know that volunteers and employees are trustworthy. Having a consistent, transparent screening process in place helps ensure that no one slips through the cracks.

Church background checks also help prevent financial misconduct in the church. A person with a history of fraud, theft, or significant financial mismanagement shouldn't be placed in a position of financial responsibility within the church. Church members want to know that their tithes and offerings are being used responsibly and for the good of the church.

Finally, background checks go a long way in creating a safe environment within the church. Screening reduces the risk of security threats and helps identify individuals with violent pasts.

Unfortunately, background checks can't 100% eliminate the possibility of something bad happening in a church. But they can go a very, very long way in reducing the risk. As a place of worship and community, churches must take all necessary precautions to protect their members and maintain a safe environment.

‍

Legal Considerations for Background Checks

There are some legal considerations that churches need to be aware of when implementing background checks.

Church Requirements vs. Legal Requirements

Some churches may have background check requirements that go beyond what is legally mandated. This isn't necessarily a problem as long as a written policy is in place that documents what the church requires.

Background checks can't be applied differently to different individuals. Every person should go through the same checks, regardless of who they are.

Compliance with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)

The FCRA is a federal law that regulates how consumer reporting agencies use and disclose consumer information. This includes conducting background checks for employment purposes. Churches must follow specific guidelines outlined in the FCRA when requesting and using these reports.

Additionally, churches need written consent from the individual before conducting a background check, and they must provide them with a copy of their rights under the FCRA if any adverse action is taken based on the report.

Consent and Privacy

All background checks require written consent from the person being checked. Churches should have a clear policy in place for obtaining this consent, and they must ensure that the individual's privacy is protected throughout the process. This includes securely storing and disposing of any personal information gathered during the background check.

Handling Negative Background Check Results

In some cases, background checks may bring up negative results. If this happens, there must be documented processes in place for handling those results. These processes should include clear steps for assessing past offenses and determining if they disqualify the person from a position within the church.

For example, the processes at your church may state that if a person has been convicted of a crime - depending on the crime - they can serve on the church greeting team but not children's ministry.

It's important for churches to handle negative results with sensitivity and confidentiality while also following legal requirements and protecting the safety of their congregation.

‍

Best Practices for Implementing a Church Background Check Process

When implementing a church background check process, there are some best practices that you should follow:

Develop A Clear Screening Policy

It's really, really, really (have I said it enough?) important to have a written, documented, clear screen policy in place. This ensures consistency and transparency in the background check process. The policy should outline what positions require a background check, what types of checks will be conducted, and how results will be handled.

As we noted above, the policy should be applied without discrimination. For example, every person who will be serving in the children's ministry should be required to go through a background check, regardless of who they are. Yes, even church leaders should have background checks if they're going to be working with children.

Use A Trusted Church Background Check Provider

You can't be too cautious when it comes to background checks, and in light of this you should use a well-established, trusted background check provider, like MinistrySafe. Look for companies that specialize in background checks for churches and have experience working with religious organizations. This ensures a thorough and accurate screening process.

It's also important to consider the legal requirements for background checks in your area, as they may vary by state or country. Your chosen provider should be knowledgeable about these laws and ensure compliance.

Ensure Regular, Ongoing Checks

Church background checks should be done regularly, not just once, before someone starts serving. This is especially important for those working with vulnerable populations, such as children or the elderly. Ideally, you should recheck individuals every 1 - 3 years, depending on their position.

Make sure to include language in your screening policy that allows for ongoing checks at designated intervals. This will help ensure that any changes in an individual's background are caught and addressed in a timely manner.

Integrate Background Checks into the Volunteer/Staff Application Process

We've touched on this, but let's make it more straightforward. Background checks should be a normal part of the volunteer and staff application process. Now, to be clear, we're not saying that every volunteer in every position needs to be subject to a background check. But, for any positions that will work directly with children, handle finances or have access to sensitive information, a background check should be mandatory. Making background checks required for everyone helps ensure that nobody gets through who shouldn't.

Keep Results Confidential

All results of a church background check should be kept confidential and private. This means that only those who need to know the results should have access to them.

Ensure that all individuals in your organization know this and take it seriously. Maintaining the privacy and dignity of those undergoing background checks is essential, even if they come back with concerning results.

Train Staff On Child Safety Procedures

Background checks are critical, but they're not 100% effective against all forms of misconduct. Specific training for staff and volunteers who will be working directly with children is also important.

This training should cover topics such as recognizing signs of abuse, appropriate boundaries, and how to report any concerns or suspicions.

‍

Common Challenges With Church Background Checks

If you implement background checks, you may encounter a few challenges along the way.

Pushback From Staff of Volunteers

You may get pushback on background checks from volunteers or church staff. People may have concerns about privacy or trust, or they may have incidents in their past that they are not comfortable disclosing. 

It's important to address these concerns and have open and honest discussions with individuals who may be hesitant about background checks. Explain the importance of protecting vulnerable populations and maintaining a safe environment.

Cost

Yes, there's a cost with running background checks. That said, shouldn't they be one of the highest priorities in your church? Is there anything more important than the safety of your congregation? If your church can't afford to run background checks for a particular ministry, it's worth asking whether your church should have that ministry in the first place.

Interpreting Background Results

Every person has a past, and no one should be judged based on the sins God saved them from. That said, there are some incidents that are far more serious than others. How do you determine which results are a red flag?

Having clear and consistent guidelines in place for interpreting background check results is important. Consider consulting with legal or law enforcement professionals, or an organization like MinistrySafe, which exists to protect children and those who serve them, to develop these guidelines and ensure they align with your state's laws.

False Sense of Security

Even with thorough background checks, there is always a possibility that someone may slip through the cracks. It's important not to rely solely on background checks as the only safeguard for your church. Implementing additional safety measures such as screening interviews, reference checks, and ongoing training can help minimize this risk.

‍

Conclusion

You can't put a price on the safety of your church. When people come to your church, they should feel secure and protected. By implementing church background checks, you're not only protecting your congregation, but you're also showing your church values the safety and well-being of all its members. If your church doesn't have a background check process in place, it's essential that you get one in place as soon as possible.

‍