Should Churches Use CashApp?

Now, more than ever, churches need digital tools to help them receive donations. When there’s an online giving option that’s available by mobile phone or desktop, donors are far more likely to give. But with a variety of digital tools available for financial transactions, it can be difficult to choose the tool that’s right for your church.

One potential option for churches and ministries is CashApp. Similarly to Venmo, CashApp is a simple financial app that allows users to give and receive cash. But is it right for churches? In the following article, we’ll take a look at what CashApp is, and whether or not it might be right as a church giving platform.

What is CashApp?

Cash App is a mobile payment service developed by Square, Inc., that allows users to transfer money to one another using a mobile phone app. The service is intended to provide an easy and convenient way to handle financial transactions, eliminating the need for physical bank visits or traditional banking methods. Users can link their bank account, debit card, or credit card to their Cash App account, enabling them to send and receive money with just a few taps on their smartphone.

Cash App is known for its user-friendly interface, making digital payments accessible to a wide audience, including those who may not be tech-savvy. Users can transact money using a unique identifier known as a $Cashtag, in addition to using phone numbers or QR codes. The app also offers additional features such as the ability to buy and sell Bitcoin, invest in stocks, receive direct deposits, and use a free Visa-certified debit card called a Cash Card for transactions or ATM withdrawals.

Advantages of Cash App for Church Donations

Here’s how CashApp might be useful for churches looking for an easy, convenient giving option.

Can Make Tithing Easy

Using Cash App for tithes and offerings can allow church members to contribute directly from their bank account or credit card through a simple tap on their mobile apps. Making it easy to give on a mobile phone (or desktop) can ultimately encourage church members to give more consistently.

Immediate Access to Funds

With Cash App, churches receive funds instantly and directly into their business account, which is crucial for meeting immediate church needs or driving timely fundraising initiatives.

Diverse Giving Options

By incorporating Cash App alongside other payment platforms like Venmo, PayPal, and Zelle, churches can offer a variety of giving options, catering to the personal preferences of their congregation, from debit card users to those who prefer QR codes for transactions.

The downside of this is more complications for churches looking to streamline their technology.

Social Media Features

Cash App's functionality extends to social media, allowing churches to collect donations through shared $Cashtags. According to Cash App, “A $cashtag is a unique identifier for individuals and businesses using Cash App. Choosing a $cashtag automatically creates a shareable URL...where friends, family, and customers can make payments to you privately and securely.”

Of course, using this kind of feature would require churches to educate and teach their congregants how to give using social media–not convenient for all church members.

Free online giving tools for your church

Tithely provides the best online tools to help you increase generosity, manage your church, and engage your church members.

Sign Up Free

Challenges of Cash App for Church Donations

Next, let’s take a look at some of the potential downsides of using Cash App to give and receive donations for a church or nonprofit.

Transaction and Processing Fees

While personal accounts on Cash App may not incur transaction fees, using a business account for church donations is a different story. According to Cash App, “Cash App will automatically deduct a 2.75% processing fee on each payment you receive to your Cash for Business account.”

Integration Issues with Church Management Software

It's crucial for churches to use tools that work well together. Ideally, a church's contact list should easily connect with its donation system. However, when churches use Cash App, they're adding another piece of technology to their setup, which could actually create more tasks for church staff and leaders. For instance, if someone donates through Cash App, their information doesn't automatically link up with the church's contact list. This means that giving history won’t be looped in with the rest of someone’s contact information. 

Tax Reporting Challenges with Cash App

One significant consideration for churches when using Cash App is its limitations around tax reporting. Unlike more traditional church giving platforms, Cash App does not offer end-of-year reporting for donations. This feature is crucial for both the church and its donors, as it simplifies the process of claiming donations as tax-deductible expenses.

Without the automatic generation of donation statements, churches face the challenging task of manually reporting all contributions made through Cash App. This not only increases the administrative workload but also leaves room for potential errors in record-keeping. For donors, the lack of immediate, accessible records can complicate their personal tax filings.

Finally, the IRS requires detailed documentation for tax-deductible donations, including the amount given, the date of the donation, and the receiving organization's details. The absence of a reporting system within Cash App means churches must develop a separate process to ensure all these details are accurately communicated to donors. Ultimately, a church giving platform should make filing taxes and contribution statements as easy as possible!

Financial Management Hurdles

Using apps like Cash App to move money around can make things super easy, but it also means church leaders need to keep a close eye on the finances. This helps stop any mix-ups and makes sure every donation goes where it's supposed to, supporting what the church stands for and keeping things in line with tax rules. It cannot be overstated that integrity and honesty are incredibly important when it comes to church finances!

A Better Alternative to Cash App?

Like Venmo or Zelle, Cash App is one more easy-to-use tool for giving and receiving cash. Although it promises convenience and efficiency, it’s not really designed for churches. Churches looking for online giving options should instead look to tools that are specifically tailored for church donations–like Tithely.

Tithely is a free online giving tool, charging minimal transaction fees and supporting tithes and offerings via credit/debit cards, ACH/bank transfers, and even check scanning.

Tailored specifically for church donations, Tithely ensures security in transactions and comes packed with features aimed at enhancing the church giving experience. These include detailed reporting capabilities, like generating annual tax statements, and convenient options for donors like covering transaction fees, text-to-give, and setting up recurring donations.

Tithely doesn't stop there; it offers users a comprehensive toolkit for church leaders and administrators to manage their congregants and communicate. This includes a church member database, mass email and text message tools, volunteer coordination, worship service planning, and even a platform for building a church website and app.

To learn more about how you can use Tithely for your church, click here.